“Unit” Perspective of Man

Home Forums Objectivism: The Philosophy of Ayn Rand Reading Group “Unit” Perspective of Man

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #30143
    Steve Chipman
    Participant

    Near the end of the Jan 30 discussion we talked about the “unit perspective of man” as a way of contrasting human consciousness to that of non-human animals. As I understand it this means humans are capable of forming abstractions ie. separating attributes (eg table shape) from their specific measurements. We form the concept “table” and can think about it in the absence of perceiving any specific table.(Perhaps this is what Jon was referring to when he spoke about the uniquely human ability to “think” about things in their absence.) I wonder if some non-human animals are able of doing something like this but only in a very rudimentary way. They can recognize enough similarities among entities to be able to react accordingly. For example, a young African gazelle may see cheetah X at a particular moment and learn (or instinctively know) “danger” impelling it to run. At another time, it sees another cheetah Y which may be larger, moving differently, etc but is similar enough that it again recognizes danger and runs. Although it recognizes enough similarities in its environment to be able to survive it cannot do what a human can do ie think conceptually about “cheetah” (eg in a scientific study).

    #30182
    Jon Hersey
    Keymaster

    Some animals apparently do recognize certain concretes as members of a particular group with particular characteristics; for instance, some monkeys have particular calls to warn their troops of a hawk, and other calls to warn of a snake. This, of course, requires that they—in some way—treat the concretes they encounter as units, “as members of a group of two or more similar members.”

    I think Rand or Peikoff might answer that animals do this solely or primarily on the basis of instinct.

    I’m not sure you can prove this, though, and I doubt that animals lack any form of unit perspective. For lots of concretes seeming to indicate that some animals do have some lesser form of unit perspective, see Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are? by Frans de Waal, which I reviewed here: https://theobjectivestandard.com/2018/09/are-we-smart-enough-to-know-how-smart-animals-are-by-frans-de-waal/

    Personally, I think what makes man distinctive is that he can leverage the unit perspective to reason about things in their absence, bring things not directly open to his perception down to a level he can directly perceive, and abstract from abstractions.

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.