Determinism and Purpose in “Player Piano”

by Angelica WerthArt & CultureMay 30, 2025

Paul Proteus is a doubt-ridden manager at Illium Engineering Works, which makes almost every product the residents of Illium, New York could possibly want. He got the position largely due to his father’s fame, which is why he wonders whether he really deserves it. The job comes with relatively high pay and great prestige; only those with high IQs can study to be engineers or managers. Almost all the other men are doomed to either the manual labor of the “Wrecks and Reeks” maintenance crews or the army. Poverty has been eliminated—apparently, the mechanization of the economy has reduced the cost of production so much that the state, which controls all the major factories and means of production, can easily provide everyone with basic necessities, entertainment, and a variety of appliances to make their lives easier, such as machines that cook food and wash clothes in seconds (the issue of where the raw materials for this come from is never addressed).

On Solid Ground

On Solid Ground is the hub for content from OSI fellows and affiliates, along with announcements about OSI’s programs and events. Here, you’ll find links to our team’s articles, videos, and other materials published across various platforms. And you’ll discover opportunities to support and engage with our global community.

Latest Blog Posts

Zachary Porcu and Craig Biddle on the Foundations of Knowledge

by Craig BiddlePhilosophy

Dec 23, 2025

Craig had a thoughtful discussion with Zachary Porcu on the source and nature of knowledge.

Michael Huemer and Craig Biddle Discuss Ethical Intuitionism and Rational Egoism

by Craig BiddlePhilosophy

Dec 23, 2025

Craig recently spoke with philosopher Michael Huemer about the nature and foundations of ethics.

Sunrise on the Reaping and the Causality Confusion

by Angelica WerthArt & Culture

Dec 15, 2025

Angel dives into the ideas behind Sunrise on the Reaping and why philosophy isn’t just for books.

What Even Is Cancel Culture?

by Kiyah WillisPolitics & Liberty

Dec 15, 2025

Kiyah looks at how a tool once used to call out bad behavior got twisted into a shield—protecting harmful ideologies under the banner of “free speech.”