John Taylor Gatto’s Damning Critique of the US School System

by | Sep 23, 2021 |

John Taylor Gatto was an American schoolteacher. He taught in New York City schools for 30 years, won the New York State Teacher of the Year Award—and resigned his position in the op-ed pages of the New York Times.

Over the course of his career, Gatto became a vocal critic of the public school system as we know it. In his own words: “School is a 12-year jail sentence where bad habits are the only curriculum truly learned. I teach school and win awards doing it. I should know.”

Gatto believed that school was teaching students a set of false lessons about how the world works—lessons that were greatly impeding their success in both school and life.

These lessons were:

  1. Confusion: everything taught in school is taught out of context
  2. Class Position: your world is structured around the class that you’re in
  3. Indifference: nothing is very interesting, and nothing really matters
  4. Emotional Dependency: one’s emotional state must reflect one’s test scores, prizes, and grades
  5. Intellectual Dependency: always wait for a teacher to tell you what to do
  6. Provisional Self-Esteem: your self-esteem should always hinge on the opinion of an authority figure
  7. One Can’t Hide: you’re always under surveillance, and your behavior is always being judged.

Gatto held that these “bad habits” give children a false understanding of how the world works. Not only does the school system stifle their natural curiosity—it also directly impedes children’s success in life. Gatto said:

I’ve noticed a fascinating phenomenon in my thirty years of teaching: schools and schooling are increasingly irrelevant to the great enterprises of the planet. No one believes anymore that scientists are trained in science classes or politicians in civics classes or poets in English classes. The truth is that schools don’t really teach you anything except how to obey orders.

In his second career as a writer, Gatto penned multiple books, including the bestselling Dumbing Us Down, which helped bring his observations to a broader audience and helped drive the conversation around what a more effective education system might look like.

“I’ve come to believe,” said Gatto, “that genius is an exceedingly common human quality, probably natural to most of us.”

Unfortunately, our school system diminishes it.

Level Up is a forum for sharing ideas and values that you find interesting, enjoyable, or useful toward flourishing. We invite you to submit:

  • Articles about ideas for loving life or defending freedom
  • Reviews of books, podcasts, or videos you find valuable
  • Personal-development tips, strategies, or tactics

Submissions are moderated for alignment with the purpose of the blog and may be edited for clarity and brevity. Read submission guidelines here.

Contributors here offer their own ideas, which do not necessarily reflect those of the staff or managers of OSI.

Recent Posts

Comment Policy
Comments submitted to Level Up are checked daily and moderated for alignment with the purpose of the blog, which is to share life-serving values with life-loving people. Comments may be complimentary or critical but must be on-topic and civil. Posters must use their real names (first and last). If your username is not your real name, simply include your full name at the end of your post. Comments are limited to 300 words, but we invite you to submit longer posts for publication on Level Up.